Right or Wrong (Read and vote)

• REad topic for instruction to Vote

  • 1. Male -Yes 7% [ 3 ]
  • 2. Female -Yes 18% [ 7 ]
  • 3. Male - No 26% [ 10 ]
  • 4. Female - No 47% [ 18 ]

  Total Votes : 38

• 

  Khoai

  
  khoảng 2 10 năm trước

• We had a case last week:
  
  John Doe married Jane Doe, they were trying to have children but no luck. They BOTH agree to open a sperm bank for "future use".
  2 yrs passed bỵ John and Jane Divorce (irreconcile). 3 months after finalized the devorce, Jane came down to the sperm bank and withdraw John's deposited (without his knowing), the result is a beautiful girl being born using John's "property".
  
  Now, the tricky part
  
  Jane is now sueing John for child support, they went to court and the judge had the ruling! Can you guess what is the verdict?
  
  Read the instruction for poll
  
  1. If you are Male and beleive John responsibles for child support vote
  Male - Yes
  
  2. If you are female and beleive John responsibles for child support vote
  Female - YEs
  
  3. If you are Male and beleive John is NOT responsible for child support
  Male - No
  4. If you are female and beleive John is NOT responsible for child support
  Female - NO
  
  
  P.S.: If you are leaving a reply, do you mind to tell me what you voted in your comment

  
  
  Được sửa lần cuối bởi Khoai vào ngày khoảng 2 10 năm trước với 3 lần trong tổng số.

• 

  http

  
  khoảng 2 10 năm trước

• dich sang tieng Nhat cho Thu Phuong nghe di dk

• 

  m0tintinhyeu

  
  khoảng 2 10 năm trước

• http wrote:dich sang tieng Nhat cho Thu Phuong nghe di dk

  
  
  Phải coi Thu Phương over 25 chưa thì DK mới chịu dịch

• 

  TayThi92

  
  khoảng 2 10 năm trước

• tại vì khg có sự đông` ý của John nên Jane khg thể truy cứu John về trách nhiệm nuôi con được . No 4

• 

  sql

  
  khoảng 2 10 năm trước

• If...
  
  ...she using it w/out permission
  ...no paper addressing that she or he can use it w/out other's permission
  
  then he held no responsible ...for this ... cuckoo-minded woman

• 

  2 Beauty

  
  khoảng 2 10 năm trước

• Techinically, He isn't responsible for the child support
  But sometimes we need to know the internal story to be able to voice any opinions.
  
  Morally speaking, he CAN support his child (becuz this lady isn't a stranger to him, but this lady was once his wife) ... But then morally wrong of her to even sue him for child support hahah! This is really tricky!!
  
  Yah! I would say it's all up to the guy, he isn't obligated to any responsibilities ... In fact! as someone have mentioned up there, he can sue her for the invasion of one's "property" without permission ...

• 

  lulinh

  
  khoảng 2 10 năm trước

• In fact, Jane has to pay for using John's property without his permission.

• 

  Vik_Vik

  
  khoảng 2 10 năm trước

• Ummm....yeah, no I think he isn't responsible. I mean she took his property without him knowing and now wants childsupport?? Nope.

• 

  Ti3uPhiL0ng

  
  khoảng 2 10 năm trước

• Well.. I also agree with everyone that says no because although Jane and John do agree to open a bank together, so what is his is also her. If she took the sperm without permission, she still have the right to take it, unless they were divorce in which they were. So that she is wrong not him... But it all comes to be his fault too, because he agree with the idea to open the bank, what happen to the sperm in his bank is a loss for him....

• 

  buffalo

  
  khoảng 2 10 năm trước

• Well, I'm a male, and I just vote "No". Usually if the woman choose to have a child with the sperm (from the bank), her main purpose should be the child, not support money . What if a man donated his sperm to the bank, than a strange woman recieved his sperm and a baby was born, then do you think the woman can ask for money from the mam ? Obviously not

• 

  chanmenh

  
  khoảng 2 10 năm trước

• NO
  
  I think the woman in this case is out of the question. Đàn bà gì mà kỳ vậy . She doesn't know what's she doing...sheesh

• 

  chanmenh

  
  khoảng 2 10 năm trước

• Khoai what do you mean by "we just had a case last week?" so it came on the news phải không or are u in a law class or something and debating over "this case"?

• 

  BooksRulex

  
  khoảng 2 10 năm trước

• what an evil woman,
  i must say

• 

  babemilky

  
  khoảng 2 10 năm trước

• anyway , child is innocent . dont have to know who have made mistake , but the child need to live and be loved
  isnt that a beautiful present from God
  love that child

• 

  mimican

  
  khoảng 2 10 năm trước

• kinda odd that she withdraw the sperm without his consent and now suing him for child support? geesh! sorry girls out there, but that's the decision she made and she should be responsible. however, if she's poor from the divorce or due to her marriage and had no job then he should give child support for awhile.